1. A stirred martini: compare water at the same temperature
Per glass: 55 mL London dry gin (assume 40% ABV), 15 mL dry vermouth (assume 17%), 7.5 mL plain olive brine, one strip of lemon peel and two plain pitted olives. The 77.5 mL liquid formula comes from the Olive Grove Martini. For this comparison, use measured water and chill without direct ice contact.
- Make two identical 77.5 mL bases in separate clean containers. Add 18 mL cold still water to A and 26 mL to B.
- Chill both containers in an ice-water bath, keeping bath water out of the drinks. Check the liquid with a clean thermometer and serve both near the same target, 4 °C, in matching glasses. Do not stir with ice afterward.
- Taste before garnishing. Compare alcohol warmth, the briny finish and how strongly the gin comes through. Express one peel and add two olives to each after the first sip if you want to compare the finished serve.
| Trial | Water per glass | Final per glass | Estimated ABV | Batch water |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 18 mL | 95.5 mL | 25.7% | 144 mL |
| B | 26 mL | 103.5 mL | 23.7% | 208 mL |
Both glasses start with about 24.55 mL of modeled ethanol. B puts the same amount of ethanol, brine and botanicals into a larger volume. You may find it softer, or prefer the stronger finish in A. Taste first; the calculator can’t choose. If you later strain a real 95.5 mL ice-stirred serving, the 18 mL difference is an estimate of net water gain, assuming you didn’t lose much drink to the ice or mixing glass.
2. A pear and juniper fizz: compare temperature at the same dilution
Per glass: 45 mL pear juice, 45 mL prepared unsweetened juniper infusion, 10 mL lemon juice, 70 mL sparkling water, 10 mL still water, and one rosemary sprig. Use the same bottles and food-grade ingredients for both. This trial adapts Pear & Pine and leaves out serving ice so no new melt enters the glass. Check the actual labels before offering it as alcohol-free.
- Measure the pear, infusion, lemon and still water into two identical containers. Chill A’s liquids and glass toward 5 °C and bring B’s toward 15 °C without adding ice.
- Open matching bottles of sparkling water just before service, one chilled and one closer to the warmer target. Add 70 mL to each base and stir once. Read each actual serving temperature. Both pours target 180 mL of liquid, including the sparkling water and deliberate 10 mL addition.
- Smell and taste each immediately before adding the rosemary. Note pear aroma, acidity, perceived sweetness and how sharp the bubbles feel. Add the same rosemary garnish to both after tasting. Carbonation can change with temperature and handling; to focus on aroma without bubbles, repeat with 70 mL still water in both.
The dilution is identical in A and B: 10 mL added to a 170 mL base (5.9% of the base). Neither trial has alcohol entered in the calculator. If a glass tastes different, the water arithmetic doesn’t explain it. Compare your notes at equal dilution before deciding whether to change the formula or simply serve it colder.
Method and further reading
Write down the starting volume, final liquid volume, serving temperature and time of tasting. Add water and temperature as separate variables. The comparisons above are our original examples; the numbers are modeled targets and the flavor observations are prompts, not measured results.
- Dave Arnold, Cooking Issues (2010): stirring, ice and temperature
- Dave Arnold, Cooking Issues (2010): dilution, perception and batching
Continue to the batching guide · See the calculator’s assumptions
